Main Menu
To reduce seed oil in the kitchen, we proudly fry with non-GMO, cholesterol-free rice bran oil for cleaner, better-tasting fried favorites.
Download PDFSneak Previews
-
Tostones de Cerdo Asado
Fresh pressed, twice fried green plantains topped with mojo pork or chicken, coconut sugar and habanero maple syrup. Substitute shrimp for 6 or ropa vieja for 7, lobster for 12. (Lobster Tostones Pictured)
$11
-
Black Bean Hummus
House made black bean hummus garnished with queso fresco and scallions. Served with soft naan bread for dipping.
$10.50
-
Cuban Pork Empanadas
Three flaky pastry crusts stuffed with mojo pork, fried and served with guava BBQ sauce.
One Order $11
Extra empanada $3
-
Crab Dip
Warm crab dip served with garlic crostini.
$18
-
Yuca Cheese Bites
Yuca bites stuffed with white cheese, golden fried and served with tomato aioli.
$9
-
Charred Octopus & Hash
Charred octopus tentacle served with chorizo-yuca hash, pickled onions, and chimichurri sauce.
$21
-
Tavern Smoked Wings
Eight chicken wings seasoned, smoked, fried crispy, and tossed in your choice of guava BBQ, hot honey, buffalo jerk, Tuscan parmesan, or pineapple cilantro chili.
$16.50
-
Conch Fritters
House-made, golden fried and served with island remoulade.
4 for $15
7 for $19
-
Drunken Shrimp Cocktail
Five sweet white shrimp simmered in Intracoastal Southern Style Amber Ale. Served with Key Lime Cocktail Sauce.
$14
-
Yard Bird on A Stick
Island spiced chicken skewers with cilantro lime dipping sauce.
$13
gluten free
-
Truffle Fries
Bowl of crispy fries tossed in truffle oil and topped with freshly grated parmesan cheese. Substitute tri-color sweet potato fries for 4.
$12
-
Smoked Fish Dip
Served with a sweet jalapeño relish, house-made plantain chips, and crackers.
$14
-
Guacamole & Chips
Freshly made guacamole topped with pico de gallo served with house-made plantain chips.
$13.50
Soups and Salads
Add to your salad: chicken for 7, shrimp for 9, grouper for 14, sirloin or lobster for 16. Dressing Selections: Tuscan parmesan. ranch, bleu cheese, honey mustard, lemon caper vinaigrette, roasted red pepper vinaigrette, balsamic, raspberry balsamic, or Caesar-
Salad Combo
Small House Salad or Chopped Caesar with a cup of soup.
$13
-
Bahamian Conch Chowder
Island-style chowder with ground conch.
Cup $7
Bowl $9.50
-
Caribbean Black Bean Soup
An island inspired vegan black bean soup.
Cup $4.50
Bowl $6.50
-
House Salad
A blend of mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, radishes, and cucumbers.
Small $8
Large $13
gluten free
-
Spring Spinach Salad
Spinach, kale, blueberries, strawberries, grilled pineapple, candied walnuts, gorgonzola cheese and raspberry balsamic vinaigrette.
$17
gluten free
-
Chopped Caesar
Chopped romaine, aged parmesan cheese, and garlic crostini.
Small $8
Large $13
-
Mediterranean Salad
Mixed greens, red onions, sliced olives, cucumbers, feta cheese, chickpeas, grape tomatoes, and roasted red pepper vinaigrette.
$18.50
Burgers
8-ounce, charbroilled steakburger served on a toasted brioche bun and a garnish of pineapple-coconut slaw. Lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles unless otherwise noted. Upgrade to bison for 5. Enjoy a gluten free bun for 1.-
Premiere Burger
Choice of cheddar, American, Swiss or smoked mozzarella cheeses.
$16
-
Guava BBQ Burger
Apple cider bacon, cheddar cheese, guava BBQ, and crispy onion strings.
$17
-
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Truffle herb mayo, panko breaded and fried portabella mushroom cap and Swiss cheese.
$19
-
Havana Burger
Topped with mojo pork, jalapeños, guava jalapeño aioli, rum-glazed onions, and melted Swiss.
$19
-
NEW RELEASE - Southernmost Bison Burger
Guava pimento cheese, fried green tomato, apple cider bacon, cilantro lime sauce, lettuce, and pickled onions.
$22
-
Garbanzo Burger
House-made chickpea burger with red pepper aioli, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle, served on a toasted brioche bun.
$15
Sandwiches
Served with a small side of grilled pineapple-coconut slaw.-
Our Signature Sandwich-Papa’s Cuban
Slow-roasted mojo pork, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, Swiss cheese, and pickle slices on pressed authentic Cuban bread.
Half $10
Whole $12.50
-
Cuban Combo
Comes with your choice of a cup of soup, or a small salad, or any regular side.
$16
-
Cubano De Ropa Vieja
Ropa vieja, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, Swiss cheese, and pickle slices on pressed authentic Cuban bread.
$19
-
Cubano De Croqueta
Fried croquets, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, tomato aoli, Swiss cheese, and pickle slices on pressed authentic Cuban bread.
$15
-
Cubano de Langosta
Cilantro butter poached lobster knuckle and claw meat, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, Swiss, pickle slices, and remoulade sauce on a pressed authentic Cuban bread.
$27
-
Mojo Pork Grilled Cheese
Mojo Pork, smoked mozzarella, cheddar, truffle mayo and bacon onion jam, served on Texas toast.
$15
-
Caprese Chicken Melt
Grilled chicken with fresh basil, sliced tomato, melted fresh mozzarella cheese, pesto aioli and balsamic glaze, served on coconut bread.
$18
-
NEW RELEASE - Grouper Sandwich
Grilled, blackened, jerked or fried grouper fillet with spicy tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle, served on a toasted brioche bun.
$19
-
NEW RELEASE - Island Steak Wrap 22
Chimichurri marinated sirloin with guava jalapeño aioli, lettuce, tomato, rum-glazed onions and maduros, wrapped in a 12” flour tortilla.
$22
-
Buffalo Jerk Chicken
Fried chicken thighs tossed in buffalo jerk sauce, topped with gorgonzola, celery ranch, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle, served on a toasted brioche bun.
$19
-
Tropical Pork Sandwich
Mojo pulled pork tossed in guava BBQ sauce and topped with grilled pineapple salsa, served on a toasted brioche bun.
$15
-
Grilled Garden Stack
Grilled zucchini, yellow squash, scallions, red onions, portobello mushroom, smoked mozzarella, roasted red pepper aioli and balsamic glaze. Choose as a sandwich served on coconut bread or served with a side salad.
$14
Main Event
Add a Small House Salad or Chopped Caesar for 6.-
Key West Bowl*
Pulled mojo pork or chicken over seasoned black beans and jasmine rice with chimichurri, maduros, and grilled pineapple salsa.
$17
Sub Shrimp $6
Sub Ropa vieja $7
Grouper $10
Sub Lobster or Sirloin $12
Add Avocado or Fried Egg $2.75
gluten free
-
Snapper Hemingway
Pan-fried panko-crusted snapper fillet topped with lump crab meat beurre blanc and served with rice caribe and grilled asparagus.
$36
-
Santiago's Catch
Crispy fried whole fish topped with chimichurri, served with red beans and rice, vegetable medley, tostones and authentic house-made Old Sour Sauce.
Market Price
-
Lobster Ravioli
Served with lobster sherry bechamel, garnished with parmesan cheese and a baby arugula nest.
$27
-
Ernest's Rib Platter
One-pound of our smoked in-house baby back ribs, basted with guava BBQ sauce, served with fries and island macaroni salad.
$26
Truffle your Fries Add $2
gluten free
-
Crabs on the Dock
2 crab cakes patties prepared grilled, jerked or blackened. Topped with key lime beurre blanc and baby arugula. Served with vegetable medley and yuca fries.
$30
-
Guava Jerk Sirloin
Served with loaded mashed potatoes, parmesan broccoli and guava jerk sauce, topped with crispy fried onions.
$29
-
Tavern Tacos
Choose mojo pork or chicken. Grilled flour tortillas, shredded cabbage, sweet pickled onions, radishes, queso fresco, cilantro lime sauce, and fresh jalapeños.
$14.50
Add guacamole $3
Sub Shrimp Add $6
Sub Ropa Vieja Add $7
Add Grouper $10
Sub Sirloin or Lobster Add $12
-
Linguini Carbonara
Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, Parmesan cheese, cream sauce, finished with egg yolk and served with naan bread.
Without additional protein $16
Add Chicken $7
Add Shrimp $9
Add Grouper $14
Add Lobster or Sirloin $16
-
Chickpea Pasta Primavera
Sautéed zucchini, yellow squash, red onions, carrots, red and green bell peppers, grape tomatoes, broccoli, parmesan cheese and chickpea penne pasta tossed in lemon caper vinaigrette.
$16
Sides
All sides are four and a half bucks.-
vegetable medley
-
French fries
-
garlic mashed potatoes
-
tostones
-
maduros
-
yuca fries
-
Plantain Chips
-
black beans and rice
-
grilled pineapple slaw
-
fresh fruit
Premium Sides
All premium sides are six and a half bucks.-
asparagus
-
mac 'n cheese
-
truffle fries
-
red beans and rice
-
rice caribe
-
truffle yuca fries
-
Parmesan garlic broccoli
-
loaded garlic mashed potatoes
-
tostones al ajillo
Sides with Attitude
-
Island macaroni salad
$8
-
Fried Green Tomatoes
Topped with remoulade drizzle and baby arugula.
$8
-
Tri-color sweet potato fries
Regular $8
Truffle your fries $10
-
Crispy brussels sprouts
Choice of: buffalo gorgonzola, pineapple thai queso, tuscan parmesan, balsamic feta.
$10
-
Chorizo and yuca hash
$11
Please inform your server of any allergies or dietary restrictions.
*Consuming raw, undercooked animal protein such as beef, poultry, fish, shellfish, eggs, or pork may be hazardous to your health.