Menus

ORDER ONLINE

Black Bean Hummus

A made in-house black bean spread with island spices served with soft naan bread for dipping and garnished with queso fresco and scallions.

$10
Cuban Pork Empanadas

Flaky pastry crusts stuffed with mojo pork, fried and served with guava BBQ sauce.

$8

Extra empanadas $3
Tavern Smoked Wings

Seven chicken wings seasoned then smoked, fried crispy, and tossed in your choice of guava BBQ, buffalo jerk, pineapple Thai chili, Tuscan Parmesan, or our house spice dry rub.

$14
Conch Fritters

Homemade, golden fried, and served with island remoulade.

4 for $10

7 for $13
Drunken Shrimp Cocktail

Five sweet white shrimp simmered in amber ale. Served chilled with key lime cocktail sauce.

$12
Yard Bird on A Stick

Island-spiced chicken skewers with avocado lime dipping sauce.

$9.50

gluten free
Tostones de Cerdo Asado

Fresh-pressed, twice fried green plantains, topped with coconut sugar, mojo pork and habanero maple syrup. GF

$10
Truffle Fries

Bowl of crispy fries tossed in truffle oil and topped with freshly grated Parmesan cheese.

$11
Smoked Fish Dip

Served with a sweet jalapeño relish, homemade plantain chips, and crackers.

$10.50
Lobster Spinach and Artichoke Dip

Warm Maine lobster dip served with toasted naan bread.

$18.50
Italian Risotto Croquettes

Black truffle and portabella mushroom risotto croquettes served with spicy marinara, balsamic glaze and Parmesan cheese.

$14.50
Charred Octopus & Hash

Sous vide octopus tentacle charred on fire grill served with a chorizo-yuca hash and chimichurri.

$19
Guacamole & Chips

Homemade guacamole served with plantain chips and pico de gallo.

$12.50

Salad Combo

A lighter sized House or Caesar salad with a cup of soup.

$9.50
Bahamian Conch Chowder

Island-style chowder with ground conch and island spices.

Cup $5.50

Bowl $8
Caribbean Black Bean Soup

An island inspired vegan black bean soup.

Cup $3

Bowl $5
House Salad

A blend of mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, radishes, and cucumbers.

Small $6

Large $9.50

gluten free
Wedged Caesar

Petite romaine, aged Parmesan cheese, and focaccia croutons.

Small $7

Large $10.50
Mile Marker Zero Caprese Salad

Mixed greens with grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze, chimichurri drizzle and chiffonade basil.

$12.50

gluten free
French Mediterranean Connection

Mixed greens, olives, roasted red bliss potatoes, zucchini, yellow squash and fried garbanzo beans. Served with roasted red pepper vinaigrette.

$14.50

Premiere Burger

Served on a toasted brioche bun. Choice of cheddar, American, Swiss or smoked mozzarella cheeses.

$11
Havana Burger

Topped with mojo pork, jalapeños, guava jalapeño aioli, rum-glazed onions, and melted Swiss.

$14
Guava BBQ Burger

With bacon, cheddar cheese, guava BBQ sauce and crispy onion strings.

$13
Mushroom Swiss Burger

With truffle herb mayo, a breaded and fried portabella mushroom cap and Swiss cheese.

$15
Big Game Burger

Grass fed bison patty served on a brioche bun topped with avocado, fried over easy egg and a balsamic glaze.

$18
Chorizo Manchego Burger

7oz. Chorizo and beef patty on a brioche bun with roasted red pepper aioli, Manchego cheese, pickled red onions and arugula.

$15

Our Signature Sandwich-Papa’s Cuban

Slow roasted mojo pork, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, Swiss cheese, and pickle slices on pressed authentic Cuban bread.

Half $8

Whole $10
Cuban Combo

A whole Cuban sandwich with choice of regular side or a small salad or soup cup.

$12
Mojo Pork Grilled Cheese

Smoked mozzarella and cheddar on Texas toast with truffle mayo, bacon-onion jam, and our mojo pork.

$12
Grilled Garden Stack

Choose between being served on coconut bread or served with a side salad. Made with grilled zucchini, yellow squash, scallions, red onions, and portabella mushroom, topped with smoked mozzarella, roasted red pepper aioli and a balsamic glaze.

$12
Bahamian Yard Bird Sandwich

Caribbean jerk, blackened or mojo grilled chicken breast on coconut bread with a guava jalapeño aioli, lettuce, tomato, rum-glazed onions and fried sweet plantains.

$14
Tropical Pork Sandwich

Mojo pulled pork tossed with our guava BBQ sauce and roasted pineapple salsa served on a toasted brioche bun.

$13
Snapper Sandwich

Grilled, blackened, jerked or fried snapper fillet with spicy tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle served on a toasted brioche bun.

$16
Caprese Chicken Melt

Grilled chicken served on coconut bread with fresh basil, thin sliced tomato, melted fresh mozzarella cheese, creamy pesto aioli and a rich balsamic glaze.

$14
Garbanzo Burger

Homemade chickpea patty with red pepper aioli, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle, served on brioche bun.

$12
Caribbean Fried Chicken Sandwich

Chicken thigh battered and fried served on a brioche bun with smoked pineapple jam, queso fresco, cilantro-lime sauce, apple cider bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle.

$18

Key West Bowl

Pulled mojo pork or chicken over seasoned black beans and jasmine rice with chimichurri sauce, grilled pineapple salsa and fried plantains.

$15

gluten free

Sub Snapper or Shrimp Add $4

Sub Lobster or Skirt Steak Add $8
Santiago's Catch

Crispy fried whole fish topped with chimichurri served with black beans and rice, vegetable medley, tostones, and authentic homemade Old Sour Sauce. Market Price
Snapper Hemingway

Pan-fried panko-crusted snapper fillet topped with lump crab meat beurre blanc and served with rice caribe and grilled asparagus.

$28
Ernest's Rib Platter

One pound of our smoked in-house baby back ribs, basted with guava BBQ sauce and served with fries and pineapple coconut coleslaw. Truffle your fries for three bucks.

$20.50

gluten free

Truffle your Fries Add $2
Cuban Skirt Steak

Fire grilled marinated skirt steak served with asparagus and red beans & rice and topped with chimichurri sauce.

$25
Linguini Carbonara

Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, Parmesan cheese, cream sauce, finished with egg yolk and served with naan bread.

$13.50

Add chicken $4

Add shrimp or snapper $8

Add lobster $12
NEW RELEASE - Bison Bolognese

Grass fed bison slow cooked in a tomato based sauce served with linguini and topped with parmesan cheese, balsamic glaze and fried basil garnish.

$20
Tavern Tacos

Grilled flour tortillas, fresh jalapeños, sweet pickled onions, radish, shredded cabbage, queso fresco, and cilantro lime sauce. Choose mojo pork or chicken.

$11

Add guacamole $2

Sub Snapper, or Shrimp Add $4

Sub Skirt Steak or Lobster Add $8

Vegetable Medley
French fries
tostones
fried plantains
yucca fries
Plantain Chips
black beans and rice

asparagus
Mac 'N Cheese
red beans and rice
truffle fries
rice Caribe

Black Bean Hummus

A made in house black bean spread with island spices served with plantain chips for dipping and garnished with queso fresco and scallions.

$10
Charred Octopus & Hash

Sous vide octopus tentacle charred on fire grill served with a chorizo-yuca hash and chimichurri.

$19
Yard Bird on a Stick

Island spiced chicken skewers with cilantro lime dipping sauce.

$9.50

Caribbean Black Bean Soup

An island inspired vegan black bean soup.

Cup $3

Bowl $5
House Salad

A blend of mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, carrots, radishes and cucumbers.

Large $9.50

Small $6
Mile Marker Zero Caprese Salad

MIxed greens with grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze, chimichurri drizzle and chiffonade basil.

$12.50
Grilled Garden Stack Salad

Grilled zucchini, yellow squash, scallions, red onions and portabella. Topped with smoked mozzarella, roasted red pepper aioli and balsamic glaze served with a small house salad.

$12

Key West Bowl

Pulled mojo pork or chicken over seasoned black beans and jasmine rice with chimichurri sauce, grilled pineapple salsa and fried plantains. Substitute snapper, or shrimp for four bucks, lobster for eight bucks.

$15

Sub Snapper or Shrimp Add $4

Sub Skirt Steak or Lobster Add $8
Ernest’s Rib Platter

One pound of our smoked in-house baby back ribs, basted with guava BBQ sauce and served with pineapple coconut coleslaw and an additional side of your choosing.

$20.50

Floribbean Shrimp & Grits (GF)

Seared blackened shrimp, cilantro Swiss polenta, and bacon pepper gravy topped with an arugula garnish.

$16

gluten free
Coconut Rum French Toast

Served with plantain butter, maple syrup, and whipped cream.

$10
Chicken & Waffle Sliders

Belgian waffle, crispy fried chicken thighs served with plantain butter and habanero maple syrup.

$14
Fruit Platter (GF)

Seasonal assortment of fresh fruit.

$11

gluten free
Papa's Platter

Two eggs cooked how you wish with home fries, English muffin, and choice of bacon or ham.

$11
Ernest's Power Bowl

Black beans, jasmine rice, 3 fried eggs, chimichurri, guacamole and 3 sweet plantains.

$13
NEW RELEASE - Truffle Avocado BLT

Apple cider bacon with leaf lettuce, fresh sliced tomatoes and avocado truffle aioli on toasted Cuban bread.

$12

Classic Benedict

Poached egg over shaved ham on an English muffin topped with hollandaise.

$12
Havana Dream Benedict

Mojo citrus pulled pork topped with a poached egg on an English muffin topped with paprika hollandaise.

$13
Yard Bird Benedict

Shredded mojo chicken, sweet plantains, rum onions with a poached egg on an English muffin topped with hollandaise and jalapeños.

$15
Skirt Steak Benedict

Thin sliced fire grilled marinated skirt steak topped with a poached egg on an English muffin with hollandaise.

$21
Lobster Benedict

Claw and knuckle meat poached in cilantro butter with a poached egg on an english muffin topped with hollandaise.

$23

Ham Croquettes (2)

Mashed potato and ham, breaded then crispy fried.

$1
Pan Cubano

Cuban bread toasted with butter.

$3
Mozzarella Tostada

Cuban bread toasted with smoked mozzarella.

$5
Spinach & Caramelized Onion Quiche

Baked custard served warm or cold.

$6
Chorizo & Manchego Turnovers

Stuffed baked puff pastry.

$4

All American*

An over easy egg on Texas toast with melted American cheese and crispy bacon.

$6
One Hand Benny*

A poached egg on an English muffin with thin sliced ham and a hollandaise mayonnaise.

$6
Our Signature Cuban Sandwich

Slow roasted mojo pork, shaved ham, classic yellow mustard, Swiss cheese, and pickle slices on pressed authentic Cuban bread.

$10

Guava & Cheese Pastry

$3
Quesito*

$3
Guava Cheesecake

$6
Key Lime Pie

$6
French Beignets

Paris Style Donuts Dusted in Powdered Sugar. Made fresh to Order.

$5 per 4

Café con Leche

Cuban espresso shot topped with steamed milk, served with or without sugar.

Single $3

Double $4
Café Americano

Cuban espresso shot, topped with hot water, served with or without sugar.

Single $2

Double $3
Café Clasico

Classic American brewed coffee.

$2.50
Café Cubano

Cuban espresso shot served with or without sugar.

Single $2

Double $3

Monday to Friday

3:29 p.m.-6:29 p.m.
$1 Off All Drafts
$2 Off Specialty Cocktails
$4 Well Liquors
$5 Margaritas
$8 Draft Wines

Tavern Margarita

1800 Silver Tequila, Triple Sec, fresh lime juice and simple syrup.

$10
Margarita Hemingway

1800 Silver Tequila, Grand Marnier, fresh lime juice, agave nectar and orange juice.

$13
1800 Hibiscus Margarita

1800 Silver Tequila, Triple Sec, fresh lime juice and homemade hibiscus infused syrup. Served with a sugar rim.

$10
Grapefruit and Basil-Tini

Deep Eddy Grapefruit Vodka, fresh basil, ruby red grapefruit juice, agave nectar and lime juice.

$9
Coconut Guava-tini

Bacardi Coconut rum, coconut cream, guava syrup and lime juice.

$9
DamGood Martini

Damrak Gin, créme de cassis, simple syrup and fresh lemon juice.

$9
Key Lime Pie Martini

Three Olives Vanilla Vodka, Licor 43, fresh lime juice and coconut crème. Served with a graham cracker rim.

$10
Fresh Espresso Martini

Three Olives Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua and a shot of our fresh espresso.

$9
Traditional Cuban Mojito

Flor de Cana silver rum with lime juice, mint, simple syrup and topped with soda water.

$9
Pineapple Mojito

Bacardi pineapple rum with lime juice, mint, pineapple juice, simple syrup and topped with soda water.

$9
Hibiscus Mojito

Flor de Cana silver rum with lime juice, mint, homemade hibiscus infused syrup and topped with soda water.

$9

Papa's Lemonade

Svedka Raspberry and Citrus Vodkas, lemonade and a splash of cranberry juice.

$9
Pain Killar

Papa’s Pilar Dark and Blonde Rums, coconut cream, fresh orange juice and pineapple juice topped with grated nutmeg.

$11
Southernmost Mule

Papa’s Pilar Blonde Rum, ginger puree, lime juice and ginger beer served in a classic copper mug.

$10
Hurricane Ernest

Gosling’s and Mount Gay Rums, passion fruit syrup, hibiscus syrup and fresh lemon juice, topped with overproof rum.

$12
Pilar Sherry Cask Old Fashioned

Hemingway’s exclusive Papa’s Pilar sherry cask aged dark rum, Dry curacao, orange bitters, and Luxardo Maraschino cherry.

$16
The Unforgettable

Vanilla Vodka, Ginger beer, blueberries and basil come together to create an unforgettable taste adventure!

$11

DRAFT - White

Hess Chardonnay Shirtail Creek, California

Glass $10

1 liter carafe $58
DRAFT - Red

Saintsbury Pinot Noir, California

Glass $12

1 liter carafe $70
WHITE - White Zinfandel

Buehler, California

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
WHITE - Chardonnay

Avalon, California

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
WHITE - Sauvignon Blanc

Whitehaven, New Zealand

Glass $9.50

Bottle $36
WHITE - Moscato

Corvo, Italy

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
WHITE - Pinot Grigio

Ecco Domani, Italy

Glass $7

Bottle $28
WHITE - Riesling

Blufield, Germany

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
WHITE - Grenache Rosé

Notorious Pink, France

Glass $10.50

Bottle $40
WHITE - Sauvignon Blanc

Bonterra, California

Glass $34
WHITE - Pinot Grigio

Maso Canali, Italy

Bottle $38
WHITE - Sauvignon Blanc

Sauvion Sancerre 2020, France

Bottle $90
Sparkling White

La Marca Prosecco, France

Split $12
RED - Cabernet

Avalon, California

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
RED - Merlot

Santa Emma, California

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28
RED - Cabernet Sauvignon

Broadside, California

Glass $9

Bottle $34
RED - Malbec

Bodega Norton Reserve, Argentina

Glass $11

Bottle $42
RED - Chianti Classico

Brolio, Italy

Bottle $50
RED - Red Blend

Château des Laurets 2015, France

Bottle $93
RED - Super Tuscan Merlot

Prima Pietra 2016, Italy

Bottle $140
RED - Chinati Classico

Badia A Passignano 2017, Italy

Bottle $150

WHISKEY & BOURBON
Basil Hayden, Crown Royal, Early Times, Fireball, High West Bourbon, High West Double Rye, Jack Daniels, Jameson, Jameson Cold Brew, Jim Beam, Knob Creek, Makers Mark, Seagrams 7, Seagrams VO, Southern Comfort, St. Augustine Bourbon, Tullamore, Wild Turkey, Woodford Reserve

SCOTCH
Balvenie - 12 Year, Balvenie - 14 Year, Balvenie - 15 Year, Dewars, Glenfiddich, Glenlivet, Highland Park - 18 Year, Johnny Walker Black, Johnny Walker Red, Macallan - 15 Year, McGregor

VODKA
44 North, Huckleberry, Absolut, Absolut Grapefruit, Absolut Mandarin, Absolut Citron, Absolut Peppar, Belvedere, Deep Eddy Grapefruit, Grey Goose, Ketel One, Three Olives Vanilla, Svedka Citrus, Svedka Raspberry, St. Augustine, Stolichnaya, Titos

RUM
Bacardi Coconut, Bacardi Pineapple, Bacardi Limon, Bacardi Dragonberry, Bacardi Silver, Barrell Private Release J907, Black Coral Silver, Black Coral Spiced, Black Coral Black Rum, Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Cream Rum, Brugal 1888, Bumbu, Bumbu Xo, Captain Morgan, Carupano Reserva 12yr Exclusiva, Coconut Cartel, Diplomatico No. 1 Batch Kettle, Diplomatico #2 Kettle Still, Diplomatico #3 Pot Still, Diplomatico 2005 Single Vintage, Diplomatico Planas, Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva, Don Papa, Goslings, Key West Legal Rum, Madi Vanilla Rum, Malibu, Myers’s, Miami Club rum, Mt. Gay, Mt. Gay Xo Triple Cask Blend, Oak and Palm Coconut, Oak and Palm Spiced Rum, Pilar Blonde, Pilar Cask #21 (Hemingway’s), Pilar Dark, Pilar Legacy, Plantation Isle of Fiji, Plantation Xaymaca, Pusser’s, Pyrat XO, Real McCoy 12 Year, Ron Zacapa 23 Year, Ron Zacapa XO, Sailor Jerry, Siesta Key Toasted Coconut Rum, Wicked Dolphin Silver

BRANDY
Courvoisier, Hennessey, Presidente

GIN
Bombay, Damrak, Hendrick’s, New Amsterdam, St. Augustine, Tanqueray

TEQUILA
1800, Cabo Wabo, Casamigos Silver, Casamigos Reposado, Cenote, Clase Azul, Don Julio 1942, Herradura, Jose Cuervo, Patron Anejo, Patron Reposado, Patron Silver, Patron XO (Coffee)

Merry Mule

Stoli Salted Caramel Vodka, fresh apple cider, ginger beer and caramel syrup. Garnished with a dehydrated apple wheel and a cinnamon stick.

$9
All Is Bright ‘Tini

Rumchata, 3 Olives Vanilla Vodka, Amaretto and sweetened condensed milk. Garnished with frosted sugar rim and a white chocolate snowflake. A sugar cookie in a glass.

$9
Papas Hot Cocoa

Baileys, peppermint schnapps, and hot chocolate. Garnished with whipped cream and crushed peppermint candies.

$9

Key Lime Pie

Homemade and topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut.

$6
Ultimate Brownie

Hot brownie with vanilla ice cream and caramel popcorn then dusted with powdered sugar.

$6
Guava Cheesecake

Guava flavored cheesecake served with guava sauce, whipped cream and blueberries.

$6
Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Served hot with caramel sauce, whipped cream, and a cherry.

$6
Sweet Plantain Bread Pudding

Homemade with Cuban and coconut bread, served warm with caramel sauce, whipped cream and creme Anglaise.

$6
French Beignets

Paris Style Donuts Dusted in Powdered Sugar. Made fresh to Order.

$5 per 4

Café con Leche

Cuban espresso shot topped with steamed milk, served with or without sugar.

Single $3.50

Double $4.50
Café con Leche

Two Cuban espresso shots topped with milk, served over ice with or without sugar.

Single $3.50

Double $4.50
Café Americano

Cuban espresso shot, topped with hot water, served with or without sugar.

Single $2.50

Double $3.50
Café Clasico

Classic American brewed coffee.

$3
Café Cubano

Cuban espresso shot served with or without sugar.

Single $2.50

Double $3.50

Kid’s Taco

Flour tortilla filled to the top with shredded cabbage, cheese and your choice of chicken or pork.

$6
Chicken Tenders

3 breaded chicken strips with choice of dipping sauce.

$6
Quesadilla

Choice of chicken or cheese.

$6
Mac & Cheese

Elbow macaroni with a savory blend of cheeses.

$6
Kid’s mini cheeseburgers

Two mini cheeseburgers on brioche slider buns.

$6

Wings

Served with celery, carrots, 8oz ranch or blue cheese

50pc $70

100pc $125
Cuban

10 whole Cubans, serves 20 $80
Empanadas

Served with 8oz BBQ sauce

36 for $45
Beef Sliders

10 for $35

20 for $65
Black Bean Soup

Pint $4

Quart $8

Gallon $30
Conch Chowder

Pint $10

Quart $20

Gallon $70
Caesar Salad

Half Pan $40

Full Pan $80
House Salad

Half Pan $40

Full Pan $80
Ribs

Half Pan $60

Full Pan $100
Shrimp Cocktail

30 for $80

60 for $140
Tropical Pork Sliders

10 for $20

20 for $35
Key Lime Pie

1 Whole Pie (7 Slices) $30
Guava Cheesecake

1 Whole Cake (12 Slices) $60

Menus

Sneak Previews

Soups and Salads

Burgers

Sandwiches

Main Event

Sides

Premium Sides

Sneak Previews

Soups & Salads

Main Event

Sides

Premium Sides

Brunch Plates

Eggs Benedict

The Perfect Compliment

Bites

Handhelds

Guilty Pleasures

Beverages

Drinks

Conch Thirty Happy Hour!

Tavern Classics

Key West Favorites

Wine

Beer On Tap

Beer Bottles

LIQUOR LIST

Holiday Drink Specials

Desserts

Coffees

Kid's Menu

Catering

Menus

Sneak Previews

Soups and Salads

Burgers

Sandwiches

Main Event

Sides

Premium Sides

Sneak Previews

Soups & Salads

Main Event

Sides

Premium Sides

Brunch Plates

Eggs Benedict

The Perfect Compliment

Bites

Handhelds

Guilty Pleasures

Beverages

Drinks

Conch Thirty Happy Hour!

Tavern Classics

Key West Favorites

Wine

Beer On Tap

Beer Bottles

LIQUOR LIST

Holiday Drink Specials

Desserts

Coffees

Kid's Menu

Catering

Email Signup